
PR people can be really bad at their jobs. That’s the simple truth. But sometimes they are so horrible that they make us all look bad. At BPB we get a lot of crapitches (my word) sent for our edification and bewilderment. I was fairly taken aback, however, to see someone actually texting a pitch to a well-respected freelancer who laughed all the way to my inbox.
Thought I’d share it with you because this is the lowest of the pitches I have seen all year. Why? To send this thinking you might get a response besides “Go away, you illiterate chump” proves this dude has no right to her gig. I won’t use her name but you know who you are - and your employer will recognize you—and maybe put you on notice: Go back to selling shoes quickly--not that there's anything wrong with that. Do it for our industry and your conscience (no, wait, you don’t have one)!
Anyway, for your reading pleasure, witness this 100% casual text pitch – with a few ideas, but a real epic fail nonetheless. It's written in a frenzy of "I don't want to take the time to edit or think," sent to a freelance journalist for a major news org, who not only ignored the crux but shared the text with friends in the biz:
i work with florida international university (FIU) school of
hospitality in miami,
a leading business school in the country specializing in the
hospitality and tourism industry
(with graduates living & working all over the world as business owners
- everything
from hotels, resorts, restaurants, catering operations, to special
events logistics companies
to department heads in major hospitality corporations- marriott, hilton, W- as
front and concierge desks, human resources, accounting, housekeeping,
beverage & revenue management departments, etc.)
and was hoping we could work together on a story
about what happens after graduation-
as you know, high schools & colleges are graduating a lot of students
come this april and may, and i would love to work with you on a story
that would
answer one of these 2 questions:
a). does an internship lead to a job? is it worth working for free?
b). what's next- how to look for a job.
as you know, i work with FIU School of Hospitality in Miami,
a leading hospitality school in the country,
a)
and i can introduce you to students who are interning,
and students who have gotten jobs as a result from their internship,
as well as employers who work with interns as well as with employers who
have hired their interns.
and one more option:
an interview with someone who got a job with another employer
as a result of a recommendation from the employer they interned for.
b). and if you wanted to work on the 2nd idea,
i can connect you with graduating seniors and academic advisor at
school about tips
she would have to land a job in this economy.
let me know your thoughts,
and we'll get it done!
thanks much,
and i'll speak w/u soon,
Oh yeah? “We’ll get it done!” Let's doubt that.
Notice the funny use of the capitalization for one word – W - instead of the other hotels mentioned. That must the chain she stays at.
Such a personalized, petty pitch proves PR (or in her case, “pr”) people push improper punctuation to perhaps too many peeps.
With that poetic note, I got to take a prolonged shower.
Twitter feed www.twitter.com/laermer
i can haz pitch? skool i iz with looking 4 a journo 2 talk bout pr with us.
ReplyDeleteThese sentences actually took more time for me to write then normal ones. Sadly, I actually had to THINK in order to appear that stupid. Fail.
Epic #prfail. Pitches like this one make it harder for the rest of us.
ReplyDeleteWhen did archy go into PR?
ReplyDeleteSometimes I get a pitch so bad, I feel like saying take me off your list, however I feel they will eventually be without a job so no matter.
ReplyDeleteThe other pet peeve is when I do respond to a PR person about their client, basically saying yes and get no response after that. I hate being used by PR people to be able to tell their clients they pitched them. Don't waste my time if you or your client really have no intention of being on the show, you just want to see if you can get a response.
Dr. Letitia Wright
The Wright Place TV Show
http://wrightplacetv.com
www.twitter.com/drwright1
Hold on, you're saying that went to the journalist by SMS? His phone must have been bleeping for hours.
ReplyDeleteGawd bless in-house numpties.
I think this is a tad harsh. Ok so the pitch wasn't great and texting it was not a good move, but imagine how bad that person must feel now.
ReplyDeletebtw please note your grammatical error "That must the chain she stays at." No one is perfect.
How embarassing! As the whirlwind of new media has swept us all away, it's important to remember that we are still professionals and must act as such at all times. Yes, we all deserve a break when we're not working, but if you're not prepared to run into your client at all times, it could mean bad news.
ReplyDeleteOnce again, thanks for the great example of what not to do!
Isn't it interesting how Anonymous thought I was harsh. Hmm.
ReplyDeleteWait, so PR folks should incorporate social media networks into their communication strategies to talk with various audiences, but not members of the media? I feel a Twitter media pitch coming...What is the reporter prefers this form of pitch?
ReplyDeleteCorrection: what if the reporter prefers this form of pitch? Isn't it possible or soon will be possible? Just a thought...
ReplyDeleteI think your reaction is harsh, too. Whether or not it is a well-written pitch, it wasn't intended to be lambasted onto the Worst PR Samples Ever page.
ReplyDeleteIt says something about your character and that of the journalist that you two would react this way in a public forum. The author is just trying to make her way in this world like everyone else. And just because we have the tools and capabilities to humiliate others publicly these days, doesn't mean we should.
Call me old-fashioned, but I prefer to be nice to everyone. (Then again, I suppose bashing other people is the point of your blog.)
Everyone knows that Anonymous did this pitch. And doesn't read the blog, eh? Cause they'd know how much real advice we give that does not bash.......... Being nice to everyone means -- don't text something to a journalist.
ReplyDelete